February 15, 2011

Charlie Don’t Surf


It’s a famous line from Apocalypse Now. Colonel Bill Kilgore insist on surfing the waves of the beaches of the Mekong Delta in Vietnam, and his men are warning him that Charlie (nickname the Americans used for the Vietnamese) is quite active in the area, i.e. they might shoot him. Colonel Bill Kilgore, your quintessential insensitive American soldier in foreign parts of the world, responds by saying ‘Charlie Don’t Surf.’
Sledding on the hills of Feraya
 This famous line came to mind yesterday, as I was sitting in the ski lift in Feraya, a ski resort some 55 kilometers in the mountains above Beirut. It was a sunny day (Sunday, that was), and thousands and thousands of people had decided to come up for the day and play in the snow. Feraya is usually only frequented by people that come and ski, but on long weekends many people come up with busses on a day trip to the snow.

And so while on the left side of the hill the skiers and snow boarders come thundering down the mountain, the right side of the hill is occupied by throngs of city people that rent sleds. And they’re having an awful lot of fun. Grown up men and women, clambering uphill, and then sliding downhill again while shrieking with laughter. It is fun to see people having so much fun. Snow is clearly not a common commodity in Lebanon.
Here's one that wishes she wouldn't have to ski ever again!

A gentleman sitting next to me in the ski lift me, saw me looking at them, and he said; “They don’t ski.”
They?” I asked.
Mohajabeen (The ones with veils). Mohajabeen don’t ski.

And indeed, practically all of the ladies sledding were wearing a veil. That is quite an unusual sight; you do not see veiled ladies ski in Feraya, unless it is the ladies from the gulf who –dressed from head to toe in black – come for a holiday with their families.

Down in Beirut, this divide is not really present. In the area where I live, it’s all mixed; tight veil, loose veil, no veil, you don’t really notice it. Several of my colleagues are veiled, but you don’t take in that detail either when you work together. Just like they probably don’t notice that I do not wear a veil.
But in Feraya, there was this very sharp divide. Unveiled ladies skiing on the left and veiled ladies sledding on the right.

And this gentleman, remarking: “Mohajabeen don’t ski.”
And that when that line came to mind; ‘Charlie Don’t Surf’.

H and I in the lift

Can someone explain the social background of this phenomena? Some anthropological wisdom please. It is not that muslims don’t ski, because I know for a fact they/we do. It cannot be a financial issue, as among the muslim society there are some very wealthy people as well. So what creates this sharp divide?

12 comments:

  1. Can't comment on the background of the issue..but I will say that that photo of your daughter (i'm assuming) is priceless! ahahahahah

    ReplyDelete
  2. The "hijab" divide is largely due to geography, and as you correctly pointed out, not due to finances.

    Look at the 5 main resorts of Lebanon
    1) Faraya
    2) Cedars
    3) Laqlouq
    4) Zaarour
    5) Faqra (even though this is private)

    These are all in heavily Christian areas.

    Now, of course you get Muslims who might live close to these areas or who have a passion for the snow, but the resorts mentioned are largely within predominately Christian areas.

    Coming from the Laqlouq, I know that the resorts, hotels, restaurants, hire places, ski instructors etc etc - are usually made up of people who live in the area or who live in neighbouring villages. So when the ski industry took off in Lebanon, it was staffed by these people, who in the majority of cases happened to be Christian.

    Another example - the Cedars (in the Bcharri region) gives discounts to people who are from that region as an incentive for them to ski.

    It is not really a sharp divide or anything malice but just a fact of geography.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Thats actually a pretty good question, I never really thought of it... but honestly, I guess they just don't know how? I mean to ski, you'd have to frequent the slopes at least three or four times a season before you really get the hang of it, and I guess maybe they just don't go up that often, or don't care for learning to ski, I don't know... what do you think?

    ReplyDelete
  4. I agree with Joseph and I also think there is a financial aspect to it. I think that historically speaking, christians were better off than muslims and skiing is a relatively expensive hobby compared to other sports. This might not be true today but it probably helped create this pattern.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Loved the post !
    I'm still waiting for an explanation that makes some sense. The "slopes are in mostly christian areas" doesn't do it for me. It's not a religion issue, I know lots of muslims who ski.

    You could argue (and it would be a bit of a stretch) that muslims of poorer financial background tend to be more religious, and therefore more likely to wear the Hijab, and so when they want to enjoy the slopes they would tend not to ski. But then again, that shouldn't stop richer veiled muslims from skiing, or poorer (non-veiled) christians from sledding.

    My best guess at this point would be: Accidental correlation, but that wouldn't explain the "Charlie don't surf" comment.

    There you have it, I have no idea why the Hijab might stop people from skiing..

    ReplyDelete
  6. Their clothes might be the main issue -

    ReplyDelete
  7. Fadi - i never said it was a religious issue. I said it was largely due to geography.

    In any case, instead of waiting for an explanation that makes some sense, go off and find it.

    And then, come back and report what you have found.

    ReplyDelete
  8. mooie foto van hanna!
    Tien moest ook erg lachen.

    ReplyDelete
  9. Perhaps skiing was seen as 'indecent' (trousers) as well as stupid? (no skiing in the couple of thousand years before the last century) and of course, skiing with a veil is quite uncomfortable.

    ReplyDelete
  10. LOL oh that poor girl! She looks drenched and absolutely miserable! Enjoy the season!

    ReplyDelete
  11. Siets,

    Wie is die anonieme die de naam van je dochter in eerste instantie verkeerd spelt en meldt dat Tineke zo moest lachen?
    Ik mis de sneeuw in Faraya (want jij blijft 't maar fout spellen) maar er zitten misschien toch mooie dingen in het vat...

    Warme groet uit zonnig Nederland,
    Theo.

    ReplyDelete